There’s an growing curiosity in utilizing cellular well being software to advance the supply of care.1,2 With the growing use of cellular units and web availability, cellular well being purposes have develop into extra accessible.3,4 The variety of health-related purposes within the Apple and Google Play shops exceeded 97,000 with roughly 1000 new purposes being added monthly.5 The worth for cellular well being adoption has develop into extra obvious with the COVID-19 pandemic.6 Among the many many elements which may influence the adoption of cellular well being is the person’s readiness and willingness to make use of it.7
Whereas the smartphone purposes might be promising for managing most of the persistent well being circumstances, research repeatedly reported boundaries associated to its adoption and use.3,8 Regardless of the rise entry to Web and smartphones, research repeatedly revealed looking for the understanding of customers’ adoption and the kind of purposes or features they are going to be fascinated by.9,10
To advance past the generic suggestions looking for the understanding customers’ adoption, researchers targeted on investigating the adoption of a specific sort of customers and age teams.8,11–15 For instance, the digital divide has been reported as a significant barrier to the adoption of diabetes-related purposes.13 As diabetes is extra widespread amongst older sufferers, the digital divide might not apply to the youthful technology. Due to this fact, understanding the sample and use of every person group is crucial for enhancing customers’ engagements and the design of user-centered software.11
To include the cellular well being purposes within the supply of care, researchers highlighted the significance of health-care professionals’ acceptance of cellular well being.3,16,17 Research reported the vital position of health-care professionals in sustaining the sufferers’ use and adoption of cellular well being purposes.18 Well being-care professionals usually tend to promote and encourage their sufferers to make use of cellular well being in the event that they use it themselves or have a optimistic perspective towards it. Research that examined the adoption of knowledge applied sciences typically or cellular well being have proven that perceived usefulness, ease of use, and accessibility are sturdy predictors of adoption and intention to make use of.22–24 These research uncovered many facilitators and boundaries to adoption of cellular well being purposes amongst health-care professionals.3,9 Research additionally investigated the use and perspective of cellular well being apps amongst medical college students as they’re the longer term health-care professionals.14,15,19–21 Whereas most of prior research concentrate on medical college students, little is thought about college students in different health-care specialties akin to nurses, dentists, and well being training and promotion professionals.
Research that investigated the usage of health-related purposes amongst college students have inconsistent outcomes. Within the UK, 79.8% of scholars said that that they had a health-related software and that IOS customers have been extra probably to make use of these purposes in comparison with customers of different working programs.21 One other research performed on college college students on the College of Bordeaux in France discovered that solely 34.9% of respondents had downloaded health-related purposes.25 Within the US, the cross-sectional survey discovered that 58% of the cell phone house owners had such a software and that health and caloric consumption purposes have been probably the most generally downloaded.26 A research performed in Greece discovered that 57.7% of medical college students had one to 5 medical purposes on their cellular units.14 In Saudi Arabia, the common use of health-related cellular purposes was unusual. Of these surveyed, 89.1% of customers reported that they had a health-related software. Roughly 73% have been occasional customers of such a software and solely 27% reported utilizing such a software no less than as soon as a day.27
To advance our understanding of the longer term health-care skilled use and adoption of cellular well being, we are going to concentrate on college college students in well being schools. The goals for our research are as follows:
- To establish the speed of adoption of cellular well being purposes in college students in well being schools.
- To establish the varieties of well being purposes utilized by well being college students.
- To establish the boundaries that forestall the usage of cellular well being purposes.
We searched the literature for related survey instruments and not one of the present surveys exactly met our wants. Due to this fact, we developed our personal survey instruments by adopting and modifying instruments utilized in prior research.3,9,20,21,26 The survey collected demographic data of scholars together with gender, age, and degree of research. The survey additionally included questions concerning the following: sample of use, identify of software, sort of software getting used, preferences concerning the purposes, boundaries, and facilitators (Appendix 1; Table S1).
A gaggle of native consultants (one statistician, two well being informatics, and two medical medical doctors) had assessed the face and content material validity of the questionnaire we developed utilizing the Lawshe validation methodology.28,29 Throughout this course of, a few of the questions have been restructured and reorganized to enhance the content material validity of the questionnaire. To evaluate the reliability of the questionnaire, we used Kappa measure of settlement and Cronbach’s alpha. We discovered vital and average outcomes of Kappa and Cronbach’s alpha which have been better than 0.5 indicating reliability and consistency within the questionnaire.
Information Assortment and Evaluation
This research was performed on well being school college students at Jazan College in Saudi Arabia. After receiving Institutional Assessment Board approval (reference quantity REC41/4/082), college students have been invited to take part within the self-administrated survey. The research individuals included female and male college students within the Public Well being, Nursing, Pharmacy, Utilized Medical and Medical Faculty. College students have been recruited by way of comfort sampling by inviting college students to take part throughout break hours. The research was performed in accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki and individuals have been knowledgeable of the research particulars and have been requested in the event that they consent to take part within the research. A written consent was additionally offered together with the survey. The focused a pattern measurement was 368 at 95percentCI. The questionnaire was translated into Arabic and was distributed on paper. The info have been later transferred into Microsoft Excel for evaluation. The evaluation was carried out utilizing Microsoft Excel and Statistical Package deal for the Social Sciences SPSS V.21. The evaluation consists of descriptive evaluation, Mann–Whitney, and chi squared exams.
A complete of 383 college students participated on this research. All individuals have been undergraduate school college students and the vast majority of individuals have been 20 years outdated or much less, greater than half 66% have been females and the remaining 34% have been males. All research individuals owned a smartphone. The general proportion of scholars who at present personal a healthrelated software was 56% (n=215/383). The gender distribution of those that at present personal health-related purposes was 49% for males and 59.8% for females.
The outcomes confirmed that (81%, n=311/383) of respondents personal an iPhone and the remaining (19%, n=72/383) utilizing different working programs together with Android. Most research individuals who owned a health-related software had three purposes or much less (80%, n=173/215). Only a few individuals reported proudly owning greater than three purposes.
The explanations for downloading the well being purposes are offered in Figure 1. When college students have been requested concerning the particular purposes they personal, the vast majority of the purposes have been within the health and train class (Appendix 2; Table S2). College students have been additionally requested concerning the usefulness of their purposes. Our outcomes indicated that 71% of the respondents agreed that cellular purposes lowered medical bills and private well being administration. Of the remaining respondents, 23% have been not sure if the purposes lowered their bills and eased well being administration and three% didn’t agree with this assertion. No vital totally different was discovered between female and male in perceived usefulness (P=0.355). We additionally calculated the chi-squared check to check the distinction in college students’ ranking of the perceived usefulness throughout those that use cellular purposes for, bodily actions, counting energy, and reducing weight, managing persistent illness, menstrual monitoring and none of them confirmed vital distinction with P=0.987, P=0.285, P=0.555, P=0.810, and P=0.440 respectively.
Determine 1 The rationale for downloading health-related purposes amongst college college students.
Cellular software utilization was explored in a number of questions. The length of software utilization diversified. Our research discovered that 28% used the applying for six months, 18% used the applying for 7 to 12 months, 20.6% used the applying for one to 2 years, and 17% adopted the applying for greater than two years. We additionally discovered that 72.3% of scholars used the applying no less than twice every week (Table 1). The Mann–Whitney check confirmed that college students who use cellular purposes to rely energy or weight reduction reported a considerably larger frequency and length of use in comparison with the opposite functions akin to monitoring bodily actions or recording menstrual cycle (Table 2).
Desk 1 The Frequency of Well being-related Functions Use Amongst College College students
Desk 2 Evaluating the Distinction within the Frequency of Utilizing the Functions and Period Customers Spent Day by day Utilizing the Functions by the Completely different Goal of Use
For potential options that college students discovered helpful, 47% (n=102) chosen “ease of use”, 36% (n=77) chosen “up-to-date data”, and three% (n=6) chosen “simply accessible”. When individuals have been requested if they’ve ever paid for a cellular software, solely 11% answered “sure” and about half of the people who gave this reply stated that they paid lower than 50 Saudi riyals (13 USD) for the applying. The outcomes confirmed that Arabic was the popular language for almost all of individuals (62%; n=134), adopted by English (32%, n=69), and each language (6%, n=12). The commonest cause for not utilizing the applying on a constant foundation was a scarcity of time (57.6%, n=124) adopted by “tough to make use of” (23.2%, n=50) (Table 3).
Desk 3 College College students Response to “Causes to Not Use Downloaded Functions on a Constant Foundation”
Contributors who didn’t obtain well being purposes have been offered with statements that inquired why they didn’t obtain the purposes. Of those that didn’t obtain the purposes (168/383, 43%), the highest three causes for not downloading have been “not fascinated by well being apps” (78/168, 46%), adopted by “My well being is sweet and I don’t want a well being app” (34/168,20%), and “complexity of use” (21/168,12%).
On this research we examined the adoption of cellular well being purposes amongst college college students. We additionally examined the kind of cellular well being software which college students use probably the most, in addition to the boundaries which can forestall them from utilizing health-related purposes.
With the rising price of persistent ailments akin to weight problems and diabetes, many research reported the vital position of cellular well being purposes in illness administration and prevention. Regardless of the speedy evolvement and technological development in cellular well being purposes, person’s resistance and low degree of utilization stay a problem.8,10,13 Well being-care professionals have an important position in selling and inspiring sufferers to make use of cellular well being purposes.18 Well being care professionals who use a cellular well being software and understand it positively usually tend to promote cellular well being purposes to their sufferers. Understanding the adoption of cellular well being purposes among the many college students in health-related schools is equally vital as they’re the longer term health-care workforce.
Each perceived usefulness, ease of use, and accessibility are a robust predictor of person’s intention to make use of and adoption of knowledge applied sciences.22–24 Our research discovered that 71% customers agreed that well being software can support in lowering well being associated value and enhance their well being. We additionally didn’t discover any distinction within the perceived usefulness between gender or between the teams utilizing cellular purposes for the totally different functions akin to bodily actions, counting energy, and reducing weight, managing persistent illness, or mentstrual monitoring. We additionally discovered that each one respondents had entry to smartphones, which displays the excessive potential of smartphone applied sciences in accessing this age group. Furthermore, our outcomes present that most of the digital divides and expertise entry boundaries reported in prior research aren’t relevant to this age group. One other vital predictor for person’s intention to make use of and adoption of knowledge applied sciences is the benefit of use.24 We discovered that solely 12% of those that don’t personal a health-related software reported the rationale for not utilizing it was complexity of use.
Regardless of the excessive variety of smartphone customers, we discovered that little over half (56%) of scholars had downloaded a health-related software. This end result was per different research performed within the US (58%) and Greece (57.7%) on this matter.14,26 Different research have reported a special proportion of health-related software house owners amongst college students starting from 34.9% in France to 79.8% within the UK.21,25 Regardless of the similarity in age and degree of training within the folks studied, there was a noticeable distinction within the degree of adoption.
To establish the kind of health-related software owned by college students, we requested them to pick the class which describes the aim of the applying in addition to naming the precise software they’d suggest. We discovered the vast majority of respondents used purposes to trace bodily exercise, weight reduction, calorie counting, and menstrual cycle monitoring. Essentially the most used purposes have been MyFitnessPal, Stepz, Sehati, Fitbit, and Hayat. Whereas most of the revealed articles about cellular well being purposes mentioned the significance of those instruments in managing persistent diseases like diabetes and hypertension, our outcomes confirmed that solely 8% to 9% of scholars who used these kind of purposes have been utilizing the purposes for this goal. An evidence for this low utilization amongst our inhabitants is as a result of age of our research (<20 years). This group may, typically, be extra fascinated by monitoring issues that weren’t persistent circumstances and will discover better use in monitoring energy, reducing weight, and holding a file of bodily exercise.13 The excessive proportion of well being software house owners who use their cellular for bodily exercise (72.5%) or counting caloric consumption (44%) means that it could be much more sensible to make the most of cellular purposes to focus on the preventative and wholesome way of life objectives than illness administration for this age group.
As well as, characterizing well being purposes with bodily exercise and counting caloric consumption might clarify why 43% of respondents didn’t obtain any sort of well being software in any respect. Essentially the most generally chosen statements have been “not fascinated by well being apps” and “My well being is sweet and I don’t want a well being app”. We have been unable to find out if 43% of respondents who didn’t obtain any sort of well being software perceived well being purposes as a illness administration software that solely utilized to folks with a selected illness or purposes that might promote a wholesome way of life and applies to anybody. Extra details about their well being standing, self-efficacy, and objectives is perhaps integrated in future research.
An attention-grabbing discovering was that the price of the applying didn’t appear to be a barrier to software use. Solely 11% of customers reported paying for an software, however this may very well be as a result of many free purposes obtainable within the market.
One limitation of our research is that we solely included college students of the well being schools which is probably not consultant of the entire college or customers of the identical age group. One other limitation was that boundaries and elements reported by college students have been restricted to the choices obtainable in our questionnaire. In future research, we suggest conducting focus teams and propping questions. This may present a deeper understanding of the elements which can affect the adoption and use of cellular well being purposes.
One advice when designing for university-age college students is to put extra emphasis on promotion and health fairly than managing persistent ailments. This will even information the design ideas in every sort of software to go well with the focused age group. For instance, apps for managing persistent illness would want to concentrate on the simplicity and ease of use to be accessible for older generations whereas health and calorie tracker associated apps may embody extra features to fulfill the necessity of youthful customers.
One other advice for future research is to leverage the facility of the totally different health-care professionals in selling the adoption and use of cellular well being. Whereas the main focus has been on physicians and nurses, we really useful exploring methods of how different health-care professionals like well being training professionals, nutritionists, pharmacists, and public well being specialists can take part in selling and inspiring the adoption of cellular well being purposes associated to their particular area.
This research offered perception into the adoption price of health-related purposes amongst college college students in well being schools. Nearly all of purposes adopted by college students have been associated to health and calorie counting. As college students undertake cellular well being purposes at a youthful age and discover them helpful, they’re extra prone to proceed utilizing cellular well being associated purposes and promote them sooner or later. Selling the adoption of these kind of purposes amongst youthful people on a big scale generally is a nice preventative well being technique since weight problems and diabetes is a world public well being burden. Investing in purposes to focus on the youthful demographic can have benefits over conventional approaches since purposes might be scaled to bigger audiences at no further value and the purposes may very well be created in a solution to monitor person knowledge and measure the effectiveness of interventions. One of many limitations of our research is that it was performed in a single college. For future research, we suggest increasing the research to a bigger inhabitants to look at the generalizability of our outcomes. We additionally suggest including focus teams for deeper understanding of the coed’s perceptions and the elements which can affect their degree of adoption.
The authors want to thank all college students who participated on this survey.
All authors have contributed to the research designs, drafting and modifying. The first creator AJ has supervised the undertaking design, execution and carried out the evaluation. The second creator WR has supervised the method of knowledge assortment, and administration of individuals. All authors critically reviewed, edited, and accepted the ultimate manuscript.
There are not any funding sources to declare.
The authors reported no conflicts of curiosity on this work and don’t have any competing monetary, skilled, or private pursuits that may have influenced the work described on this manuscript.
1. Free C, Phillips G, Watson L, et al. The effectiveness of mobile-health applied sciences to enhance well being care service supply processes: a scientific assessment and meta-analysis. PLoS Med. 2013;10(1):e1001363. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1001363
2. Marcolino MS, Oliveira JAQ, D’Agostino M, Ribeiro AL, Alkmim MBM, Novillo-Ortiz D. The influence of mhealth interventions: systematic assessment of systematic evaluations. JMIR Mhealth Uhealth. 2018;6(1):e23. doi:10.2196/mhealth.8873
3. Gagnon M-P, Ngangue P, Payne-Gagnon J, Desmartis M. m-Well being adoption by healthcare professionals: a scientific assessment. J Am Med Inform Assoc. 2015;23(1):212–220. doi:10.1093/jamia/ocv052
4. Ricciardi L, Mostashari F, Murphy J, Daniel JG, Siminerio EP. A nationwide motion plan to assist shopper engagement by way of e-health. Well being Aff. 2013;32(2):376–384. doi:10.1377/hlthaff.2012.1216
5. Peng W, Kanthawala S, Yuan S, Hussain SA. A qualitative research of person perceptions of cellular well being apps. BMC Public Well being. 2016;16. doi:10.1186/s12889-016-3808-0
6. Bokolo AJ. Software of telemedicine and eHealth expertise for medical companies in response to COVID‑19 pandemic. Well being Technol (Berl). 2021;11(2):359–366. doi:10.1007/s12553-020-00516-4
7. Anthony B. Implications of telehealth and digital care options throughout COVID-19 pandemic: a qualitative literature assessment. Inform Well being Soc Care. 2021;46(1):68–83. doi:10.1080/17538157.2020.1839467
8. LeRouge C, Van Slyke C, Seale D, Wright Ok. Child boomers’ adoption of shopper well being applied sciences: survey on readiness and boundaries. J Med Web Res. 2014;16(9):e200. doi:10.2196/jmir.3049
9. Kwon M, Mun Ok, D’Angelo J, McLeod DM, Lee J. Integrating cellular communication applied sciences into public well being: figuring out the motivational elements of well being app engagement.
10. Fahad Aldhaban TUD, Harmon R. Exploring the adoption and use of the smartphone expertise in rising areas.
11. Wang Y, Min J, Khuri J, et al. Effectiveness of cellular well being interventions on diabetes and weight problems therapy and administration: systematic assessment of systematic evaluations. JMIR Mhealth Uhealth. 2020;8(4):e15400. doi:10.2196/15400
12. Winter SJ, Sheats JL, King AC. The usage of habits change methods and idea in applied sciences for heart problems prevention and therapy in adults: a complete assessment. Prog Cardiovasc Dis. 2016;58(6):605–612. doi:10.1016/j.pcad.2016.02.005
13. Jabour A, Jones JF. Facilitators and boundaries to sufferers’ engagements with private well being data: systematic assessment.
14. Chatzipavlou I, Misirlis N, Vlachopoulou M. Smartphone medical app use: a survey amongst medical college students at Aristotle College of Thessaloniki. MCIS 2015Proc. 2015.
15. Cho J, Quinlan MM, Park D, Noh GY. Determinants of adoption of smartphone well being apps amongst school college students. Am J Well being Behav. 2014;38:860–870. doi:10.5993/AJHB.38.6.8
16. Leigh S, Ashall-Payne L, Andrews T. Boundaries and facilitators to the adoption of cellular well being amongst well being care professionals from the UK: discrete alternative experiment. JMIR Mhealth Uhealth. 2020;8(7):e17704. doi:10.2196/17704
17. Gagnon M-P, Desmartis M, Labrecque M, et al. Systematic assessment of things influencing the adoption of knowledge and communication applied sciences by healthcare professionals. J Med Syst. 2012;36(1):241–277. doi:10.1007/s10916-010-9473-4
18. Miyamoto SW, Henderson S, Younger HM, Pande A, Han JJ. Monitoring well being knowledge is just not sufficient: a qualitative exploration of the position of healthcare partnerships and mHealth expertise to advertise bodily exercise and to maintain habits change. JMIR mHealth uHealth. 2016;4(1):e5. doi:10.2196/mhealth.4814
19. Jebraeily M, Fazlollahi ZZ, Rahimi B. The commonest smartphone purposes utilized by medical college students and boundaries of utilizing them. Acta Informatica Medica. 2017;25(4):232–235. doi:10.5455/intention.2017.25.232-235
20. Quant C, Altieri L, Torres J, Craft N. The self-perception and utilization of medical apps amongst medical college students in america: a cross-sectional survey. Int J Telemed Appl. 2016;2016:5. doi:10.1155/2016/3929741
21. Payne KB, Wharrad H, Watts Ok. Smartphone and medical associated app use amongst medical college students and junior medical doctors in the UK (UK): a regional survey. BMC Med Informat Decis Making. 2012;12. doi:10.1186/1472-6947-12-121
22. Garavand A, Samadbeik M, Nadri H, Rahimi B, Asadi H. Efficient elements in adoption of cellular well being purposes between medical sciences college students utilizing the UTAUT mannequin. Strategies Inf Med. 2019;58(04/05):131–139. doi:10.1055/s-0040-1701607
23. Mittal A, Aggarwal A, Mittal R. Predicting college college students’ adoption of cellular information purposes: the position of perceived hedonic worth and information motivation. Int J E-Serv Cellular Appl. 2020;12(4):42–59. doi:10.4018/IJESMA.2020100103
24. Larcker DF, Lessig VP. Perceived usefulness of knowledge: a psychometric examination. Decis Sci. 1980;11(1):121–134. doi:10.1111/j.1540-5915.1980.tb01130.x
25. Montagni I, Cariou T, Feuillet T, Langlois E, Tzourio C. Exploring digital well being use and opinions of college college students: area survey research. JMIR mHealth uHealth. 2018;6(3):e65. doi:10.2196/mhealth.9131
26. Krebs P, Duncan DT. Well being app use amongst us cell phone house owners: a nationwide survey. JMIR mHealth uHealth. 2015;3:e101. doi:10.2196/mhealth.4924
27. Sayedalamin Z, Alshuaibi A, Almutairi O, Baghaffar M, Jameel T, Baig M. Utilization of good telephones associated medical purposes amongst medical college students at King Abdulaziz College, Jeddah: a cross-sectional research. J Infect Public Well being. 2016;9:691–697. doi:10.1016/j.jiph.2016.08.006
28. Lawshe CH. A quantitative strategy to content material validity. Pers Psychol. 1975;28(4):563–575. doi:10.1111/j.1744-6570.1975.tb01393.x
29. Taherdoost H. Validity and reliability of the analysis instrument; the right way to check the validation of a questionnaire/survey in a analysis. The best way to check the validation of a questionnaire/survey in a analysis (August 10, 2016). 2016.